After the Second World War, men were getting back home. As a result, the
birthrate was pretty high until 1965 (The Canadian Encyclopedia, n.d.). Those
people who were born in that time period are called the baby-boomer generation (The
Canadian Encyclopedia, n.d.). Each time
period has its specific generation. People who are born between 1980 and 1995
are called the millennial generation (CBS, February 11, 2009). There are a lot
of prejudices related to this generation. One of them is that the millennials
are self-centered, so they do not get involved in their community.
First, I do not think that there is a lack of participation in community
service for the millennials. In fact, Jean Twenge, a psychology professor,
states that ‘’youth volunteerism has actually risen in the last decade’’ (Ray
Williams, June 6, 2010). Two main reasons could explain this situation. First
of all, millennials were raised with the idea that a person can do whatever he
or she wants. It may have made spoiled people, but those people have big
dreams. They want to have a positive impact in their world. Community service
is a good start. Second of all, more and more people attend university. On the
work market, if a person wants to be noticed, he or she has to have something
more than a piece of paper. Employers search for candidates with various
experiences. It is the same thing for the admission in universities. In the
United States, for example, the community service is essential to get to the
most prestigious schools. More close to us, there are programs, like the
international program at Joseph-Harmas Leclerc in Granby and at Jean-Jacques
Bertrand in Farnham, that include hours of community service. It goes the other
way around too. There are a lot of schools. To attract the greatest students,
schools have to offer other things than good classes. Students will check what
the other opportunities are. Is there international exchange? Are there
possibilities of social involvement?
Second, I think that volunteering is better than service learning.
Volunteer Canada describes volunteering as ‘’people [who] work to improve the
lives of their neighbours and, in return, enhance their own’’ (Kaylan C.
Schwarz, Fall 2013). On the other hand,
service learning provides volunteering in addition of preparatory orientation,
classroom activities and structured reflection (Kaylan C. Schwarz, Fall 2013). I
prefer volunteering for two reasons. First of all, the work load of service
learning is demoralizing. Students will not be motivated to do the volunteering
if there is some other heavy work to do. They will not understand the essence
of community service which is helping not getting a good mark. Second of all,
students are able to think by themselves. There is no need of someone else to
ask them questions about their experience and their learning. If the
volunteering has a positive or negative outcome the student will notice it by
himself. There is no need for a rigid framework.
Third, I think that schools should not force students to do
volunteering, but should encourage it. Volunteering has positive impacts on the
communities and on students too. Community
involvement gives skills, knowledge and attitudes that are needed to be a good
citizen (Kaylan C. Schwarz, Fall 2013). It gives people a sense of cooperation,
an open-mind. The effects are not the same if volunteering is mandatory. When
someone is forced to do something, he or she is reticent even before starting.
The person will do it because he or she has to do it, but will not be motivated
and will not learn anything. Schwarz declares that mandatory community
involvement ‘’cannot guarantee equal access to meaningful community involvement
placements’’ (Kaylan C. Schwarz, Fall 2013). What schools can do is encouraging
volunteering. They can offer an optional volunteering course or give extra
credits. There are other ways to motivate young people to be involved in their
community.
To conclude, I think that millennials do get involved in their
community, that volunteering is better than service learning and that schools
should not force students to volunteer. The boomers are complaining about the
generation millennial, but who raised them? Anyway, it is not a competition for
the best generation. Each generation has their qualities and faults.
No comments:
Post a Comment